Crumbl Cookies Prices – How Much Does a Crumbl Cookie Cost?

Last Updated on January 24, 2024
Written by CPA Alec Pow | Content Reviewed by CFA Alexander Popinker

Crumbl Cookies have exploded in popularity over the past few years. The gourmet cookie company has amassed a passionate fanbase of cookie lovers who eagerly await the weekly rotating menu of creative flavors.

However, with popularity comes questions – one of the most frequent being “How much do Crumbl Cookies cost?” This article will go through Crumbl’s pricing, ingredients, and value to find out if their sweet treats are worth the expense.

Crumbl Cookies Prices

A Crumbl Cookie costs between $3,98 and $4,48, while a box of cookies costs between $11,98 and $99. Crumbl Cookies menu prices primarily depend on two factors – size and weekly flavor.

Here is a breakdown of how Crumbl Cookies are priced by size:

• Individual Cookie – $3.98-$4.48 per cookie
• 4-Pack Box – $11.98-$14.98 for 4 cookies
• 6-Pack Box – $16.98-$19.98 for 6 cookies
• 12-Pack Box – $32.98-$39.98 for 12 cookies
• Bulk Order (50 cookies) – $99.99 for a party box of 50 cookies

Prices may vary slightly by location.

As you can see, the most economical way to purchase Crumbl Cookies is in bulk quantities. The cost per individual cookie decreases significantly as the box size increases.

Specialty collaborations like the Oreo Series or more labor-intensive recipes come at a premium. For example, during Valentine’s Day, a single raspberry truffle cookie cost $4.48 while the classic Milk Chocolate Chip rang up at $3.98.

Seasonal and limited-edition flavors also fetch higher prices given their novelty and increased demand. Expect to pay a little more for unique creations.

You can expect to pay between $3.98-$4.48 for single Crumbl Cookies with prices per cookie dropping as you order larger quantities. Specialty flavors tend to sit at the higher end of that range.

Life Between Weekends also mentions Crumble Cookies. They say that a single cookie is typically priced around $4, although in some areas, the cost may range from $4.25 to $4.48 per cookie.

Reddit users have reported varying cookie prices, with rates ranging from $3.95 to $4.48 per cookie depending on the location and specific cookie shop.

An Introduction to Crumbl Cookies

For the uninitiated, Crumbl Cookies is a franchise bakery that specializes in gourmet cookie creations. What started in 2017 as a single store in Logan, Utah has since expanded to over 500 locations nationwide.

Crumbl rotates through a weekly menu of 4-5 freshly baked cookie flavors. Some fan favorites include Milk Chocolate Chip, Cornbread, S’mores, and their signature Pink Sugar Cookie. The cookies are always baked fresh in-store daily.

Beyond individual cookie and pint ice cream options, Crumbl also offers cookie cakes, a catering menu with assorted cookies that are priced for the number of cookies per flavor you’re getting, and weekly specialty collaborations with brands like Oreos. Their recognizable pink boxes have become iconic.

While Crumbl has staple flavors, they also frequently debut adventurous new creations. Recent cookies have included Ambrosia, Pumpkin Roll, Lemon Blackberry, and Caramel Popcorn. The element of surprise is part of the brand’s appeal for cookie fiends.

So why has Crumbl captured so much attention? Let’s break it down.

The Allure of Crumbl Cookies

Gourmet Ingredients – Crumbl sets itself apart with quality ingredients like real butter, pure vanilla and chocolate, fresh eggs, and real sugars. Their cookies provide an elevated experience compared to grocery store baked goods.

Creative Flavors – The weekly rotating flavors combined with specialty collaborations keep customers excited about what’s next. Crumbl doesn’t settle for just chocolate chip.

Freshly Made – Cookies are baked in small batches throughout the day so they’re warm and melty when customers receive them.

Presentation – The recognizable pink boxes tied with a bow and cookie cakes for special occasions make them perfect gifts. Crumbl is just as much about the experience as the cookie.

Community – Crumbl has fostered a supportive community, especially among return customers who look forward to the weekly cookie drops. For many, visiting Crumbl is an event.

Factors Influencing the Crumbl Cookies Menu Prices

From real butter to chocolate chips, ingredient quality is one factor that weighs on Crumbl’s pricing. Premium ingredients cost more for the company to source, driving up costs.

There’s also significant labor involved in preparing the cookies fresh daily. Each cookie is handcrafted and goes through extensive quality checks. These human resource expenses get built into the price.

Brand recognition and hype enable Crumbl to command higher prices compared to other cookie shops. When cookies consistently sell out even at premium price points, the company has less incentive to lower costs.

Supply chain and distribution likely contribute somewhat to costs as ingredients get shipped nationally to supply hundreds of locations. But Crumbl’s centralized dough production helps mitigate this.

Franchise model – since each Crumbl store is independently owned and operated, franchise fees impact pricing as well. Franchisees pay an upfront fee and ongoing royalties back to corporate.

Presentation and packaging also likely raise costs marginally given the company’s iconic pink boxes, tissue paper, and ribbons. But the unboxing experience builds excitement and brand loyalty.

While Crumbl Cookies sit at a higher price point than grocery store cookies, the quality, flavors, and experience seem to validate the extra expense for die-hard fans.

Crumbl Cookies vs Other Bakeries

To better contextualize Crumbl’s pricing, let’s compare it against other gourmet cookie companies.

Mrs. Fields – Single cookies range from $2.50-$3.50, very comparable to Crumbl. However, Mrs. Fields offers more frequent discounts like 40% off for online orders.

Insomnia Cookies – Pricing starts around $2.29 for an individual cookie, going down to $1.99 each when you buy multiples. Generally cheaper than Crumbl.

Great American Cookies – Similar pricing to Insomnia Cookies with individual cookies starting at $1.99. Great American also offers combos and discounts.

Cheryl’s Cookies – Cheryl’s is cheaper for large bulk orders (60 cookies for $59.99) but doesn’t offer fresh individual cookie purchasing.

Crumbl Cookies tend to be pricier than the average neighborhood cookie shop for single purchases but offer comparably priced bulk boxes. The trade-off for Crumbl’s higher single cookie cost is the quality, presentation, and exciting flavors.

Special Packaging Adds to the Cost

Part of what you pay for with Crumbl Cookies is the entire brand experience, starting with their packaging.

The signature pink boxes are one differentiator that likely adds nominal material costs compared to a basic box. While inexpensive to produce, the packaging builds brand identity.

Crumbl Cookies are also carefully packaged for presentation with each cookie nestled in tissue paper inside the box. For gift orders and catering, this personalized packaging ramps up the price a bit. But it enables cookies to be gifted professionally.

Ribbons and bows on specialty boxes also elevate the unboxing experience, which customers have noted makes Crumbl a great option for birthdays, holidays, and celebrations.

For many food brands, packaging and presentation impact perceived value. Crumbl Cookies lean into their gift-giving appeal with packaging details that enhance the client experience while marginally impacting cookie pricing.

Customer Opinions on Crumbl Value

On Instagram and Facebook, Crumbl has an engaged community of fans who regularly discuss the brand. What are their opinions on Crumbl Cookie prices?

The verdict is overwhelmingly positive. Die-hard Crumbl consumers acknowledge the cookies command higher prices, but strongly feel the superior quality warrants the cost.

Many customers noted Crumbl’s cookies are much larger than competitor’s offerings. The cookie itself tends to justify the price tag.

Fans also cite Crumbl’s creativity and rotation as adding value alongside staple flavors. The element of surprise makes recurring purchases worthwhile even at premium pricing.

Customers generally agree Crumbl Cookies are a great dessert worth budgeting and planning for. Some even adjust discretionary budgets to accommodate weekly Crumbl runs.

Of course, there are some dissenters. Negative reviewers argue you can get a box of quality bakery cookies for less. And locally owned bakeries offer fresh cookies at lower sticker prices.

But overwhelmingly, Crumbl consumers feel their creative recipes and large portion sizes justify the above-average pricing compared to traditional bakeries. The unique experience validates the indulgence.

Where To Buy Crumbl Cookies

Crumbl Cookies can be purchased directly from any of their 500+ bakery locations. Customers can browse the weekly Crumbl Cookies menu and place an order in-person to pick up fresh cookies on the spot. This is the best way to get your hands on popular limited batches before they sell out.

To find the nearest Crumbl bakery, visit their website which has a store locator search tool. Most locations are open Monday – Saturday.

For added convenience, customers can also order Crumbl Cookies online for delivery or pickup. Delivery is facilitated through third-party services like DoorDash and UberEats. Online ordering on Crumbl’s website or app typically has a $10 minimum purchase.

You might also like our articles on the menu prices of Cold Stone Creamery, Nothing Bundt Cakes, or Dunkin Donuts.

Crumbl also offers nationwide shipping for gift boxes, catering trays, and cookie cakes. So even if you don’t live near a Crumbl bakery, you can still enjoy their cookies!

Online ordering and nationwide shipping make Crumbl Cookies easily accessible for new customers to try. With the combination of in-store, delivery, and shipping options, cookie lovers across the country can get their Crumbl fix!

Crumbl Cookies offer various discounts and loyalty programs customers can take advantage of to save money:

• They email subscribers weekly coupons for $2 off $10 purchases or sometimes steeper discounts like 40% off.
• Students and teachers get 10% off purchases in-store when they show valid school ID.
• Healthcare workers qualify for 25% off their Crumbl order as a thank you.
• Downloading and using the Crumbl app unlocks exclusive app-only rewards and bonuses.
• Occasional in-app promotions include deals like buy 2 boxes, get 1 free.
• Loyal customers who frequently purchase can qualify for special status levels that come with free cookies, bonus rewards, and early access to new flavors.

Taking advantage of Crumbl’s discounts and loyalty programs is a great way to offset some of the cost as a regular customer.

Crumbl Cookies may come at a premium price, but devotees agree the over-the-top flavors, high-quality ingredients, and exceptional branding make them worth splurging on for special occasions and cookie cravings. For gourmet cookie lovers, Crumbl delivers an experience that validates the cost.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the three C’s of Crumbl Cookies?

The three C’s that make Crumbl Cookies stand out are:

• Craftsmanship – Each cookie is meticulously made with care using quality ingredients.
• Creativity – Their weekly rotating flavors keep the menu exciting and surprising for customers.
• Community – Crumbl has cultivated an enthusiastic community of cookie lovers who are passionate about the brand.

How unhealthy are Crumbl Cookies?

While delicious, Crumbl Cookies are quite indulgent treats. A standard 4 oz Crumbl cookie ranges from 200-450 calories depending on the flavor. The cookies are high in sugar, fat, and carbs. Crumbl Cookies are best enjoyed in moderation as a sometimes food.

What is Crumbl Cookies best-selling cookie?

Crumbl’s Milk Chocolate Chip is consistently their hottest seller. Customers love this classic, nostalgic flavor made with gourmet chocolate and real butter. It’s a crowd-pleaser and their signature cookie.

Why is the Crumbl cookie box pink?

Crumbl’s signature pink box helps make the brand instantly recognizable. The pink packaging creates a feminine, playful vibe that aligns with the joy of indulging in cookies. It also reminds many customers of nostalgic pink bakery boxes. The pink boxes bring extra flair.