How Much Does a Bakers Square Pie Cost?

Updated on September 26, 2026 | Written by Alec Pow
This article was researched using 14 sources. See our methodology and corrections policy.

A Bakers Square pie costs about $5.79 to $7.89 per slice or roughly $18.69 to $26.19 for a whole pie in the live U.S. delivery menu reviewed in September 2026. A separate Saginaw, Michigan menu tracked by PriceListo starts slightly lower at $5.39 per slice, which shows why the restaurant location and ordering channel matter.

Bakers Square is still best known for French Silk, fruit, cream, and seasonal pies, but the brand now reaches customers through two different formats. Some locations are full Bakers Square restaurants, while many others are pie-only counters inside Famous Dave’s or Tahoe Joe’s restaurants. Pickup, dine-in, delivery, and pie-only locations can show different prices.

The useful number is not one national average. It is the price of the specific pie at the location where you plan to buy it, plus any delivery charge, topping, or meal purchase tied to a promotion.

Article Highlights

• Live delivery pricing puts most pie slices around $5.79 to $7.89 and whole pies around $18.69 to $26.19 (at $30 per hour, earning that amount would take about 37 to 52 minutes, before taxes).
• French Silk is listed at $6.39 per slice and $21.39 whole on one live Bakers Square delivery menu.
• Buying a whole six-slice French Silk pie instead of six individual slices can cut the dessert bill by about $16.95 under the sampled prices.
• Free Pie Wednesday still exists at participating restaurants, but the free slice requires an entrée and beverage purchase and is dine-in only.
• A separate Pie Slice Special can add a slice to a burger or sandwich for $2.59 at participating restaurants.
• Bakers Square is part of MTY Food Group through BBQ Holdings, so the old statement that BBQ Holdings is the independent owner is incomplete.

How Much Does a Bakers Square Pie Cost?

The live Bakers Square delivery menu shows whole pies from $18.69 (about 37 minutes at $30 per hour) for Country Apple and Cherry up to $26.19 for Candy Bar Pie. Slices on the same menu run from $5.79 for Country Apple and Cherry to $7.89 for Candy Bar Pie. DoorDash warns that prices depend on the customer’s location, so these are live menu examples rather than one companywide price list.

The table below keeps slice and whole-pie prices on the same menu so the comparison is like-for-like. Cakes are excluded because Bakers Square prices cheesecake and carrot cake differently from its standard pies. Seasonal pies can also disappear from the menu outside their selling period.

Pie	Slice Price	Whole Pie Price
Country Apple	$5.79	$18.69
Cherry	$5.79	$18.69
Reduced Sugar Apple	$6.09	$19.29
Harvest Pumpkin	$6.09	$19.29
French Silk	$6.39	$21.39
Southern Pecan	$6.39	$21.39
Caramel Pecan Silk Supreme	$7.29	$22.89
Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup	$7.29	$22.89
Candy Bar Pie	$7.89	$26.19

An independent Saginaw menu price check updated in December 2025 reports a Country Apple slice at $5.39 and a Whole Lemon Supreme at $21.19. That supports using a location-specific budget instead of treating the table as a fixed national schedule.

Whole Pie Value

A whole pie becomes much cheaper per serving once several people want the same flavor. Bakers Square’s 2024 official pie menu described its standard pies as six-slice pies. Using that six-slice format as an illustrative serving assumption, six French Silk slices at today’s sampled delivery price of $6.39 each would cost $38.34 (about 1.3 hours of work at $30 per hour). The whole French Silk pie is $21.39, a difference of $16.95. The whole pie cuts the six-serving dessert bill by about 44%.

Country Apple produces an even larger percentage gap. Six slices at $5.79 each total $34.74, while the whole pie is $18.69. The difference is $16.05, or about 46%. Those calculations assume the whole pie still provides six comparable portions and do not include delivery charges or tax.

A single diner usually saves money by buying one slice. A six-person dinner is where a whole pie becomes much more compelling, provided everyone wants the same flavor and the six-slice serving assumption fits the group.

Makes sense if:

• Four to six people want the same pie flavor.
• You are taking dessert to a dinner, office, or family gathering.
• You want leftovers and have refrigerated storage available.

Does not make sense if:

• Only one or two people want pie.
• The group wants several different flavors.
• You are ordering delivery and a smaller order qualifies for a better promotion.

Location Price Gaps

Bakers Square prices are not identical across cities. A Nashville pie-only menu lists French Silk at $6.69 per slice and $22.89 whole, Country Apple at $6.09 per slice and $20.49 whole, and Lemon Supreme at $6.99 per slice and $24.09 whole. Those amounts sit above the lower prices on the broader DoorDash brand menu.

The difference can come from geography, the host restaurant, the delivery platform, or a mix of those factors. The DoorDash Nashville page says the merchant sets its menu prices and that delivery and pickup prices may differ. That makes a delivery-app price a useful budget signal, but not proof of the in-restaurant counter price. Check the selected store and order method before treating any listed price as your final quote.

Bakers Square’s own 2024 official pie menu listed French Silk at $5.25 per slice and $17.25 whole. The sampled 2026 delivery listing is about 22% higher per slice and 24% higher for the whole pie. That comparison mixes time and ordering channel, so it should not be read as a pure two-year inflation rate.

Free Pie Wednesday

Bakers Square still runs Free Pie Wednesday at participating full-service restaurants. The published promotion terms give one free slice with the purchase of an entrée and a beverage from 10:30 a.m. until close. The offer is dine-in only, limited to one slice per person per qualifying purchase, and cannot be combined with another promotion or discount.

The word “free” needs the purchase condition attached to it. A customer who was already planning to buy an entrée and beverage can reduce the incremental dessert price to $0 for an eligible slice. Someone who only wants pie would have to buy food and a drink to qualify for the offer, so Free Pie Wednesday is not a no-purchase giveaway. The meal requirement is part of the price.

There is another dine-in discount worth separating from the Wednesday offer. Bakers Square’s lunch menu terms advertise a Pie Slice Special that adds a slice to a burger or sandwich for $2.59 at participating restaurants. That offer cannot be combined with Free Pie Wednesday, and the same page says the 10% senior discount does not apply to whole pies.

Delivery and Add-Ons

The pie price can rise once delivery enters the order. Bakers Square supports pickup and delivery through its own ordering portal, while third-party services can apply their own fees, tips, minimums, or higher menu prices. The safest way to budget is to compare the pickup subtotal with the delivered checkout total before placing the order.

A catering order shows how quickly the channel can change the bill. An ezCater Chicago listing prices Country Apple Pie at $15.50 and French Silk, Lemon Supreme, and Southern Pecan at $17.50 each, with each pie listed as serving six. Delivery starts at $30 and requires a $100 delivery minimum. Those catering prices should not be substituted for walk-in or DoorDash prices because the order rules are different.

The old article’s $2.50 to $3.50 topping range, $4 ice cream pint, and $3.50 whipped cream charge are not supported by the live menus reviewed. The dated 2024 official menu instead showed several slice toppings at $1.50 and whole-pie whipped cream at $3, so those figures belong only as historical context.

For a worked order, two live-menu French Silk pies cost $42.78 before tax and delivery. That can cover twelve six-slice portions under the historical serving format, or about $3.57 per portion. Ordering twelve individual French Silk slices at $6.39 each would cost $76.68. The whole-pie route saves $33.90 before any channel-specific charges.

Pie-Only Locations

The brand footprint has changed enough that “Bakers Square location” no longer always means a full Bakers Square restaurant. The official location directory lists full restaurants alongside many “Pie Only” locations inside Famous Dave’s. California entries also include Bakers Square pies sold at Tahoe Joe’s. A customer may find Bakers Square pie in a city that does not have a standalone Bakers Square dining room.

This distinction affects both menu scope and promotions. A pie-only Famous Dave’s counter may sell whole pies and slices but not the full Bakers Square breakfast, lunch, or dinner menu. Free Pie Wednesday is written as a dine-in restaurant promotion tied to an entrée and beverage, so a pie-only location should not be assumed to participate in the same way.

The brand’s online ordering search reflects this setup by labeling locations such as Mesa, Chandler, and Peoria as “Pie Only – Bakers Square Pie in Famous Dave’s.” Customers looking only for a whole pie may gain more nearby options from this shared-brand model. Customers looking for the full Bakers Square restaurant experience need to check the location type before traveling.

Allergens and Availability

Pie availability changes by season and location. Bakers Square currently lists fruit, silk, cream, seasonal pies, cheesecake, and carrot cake, while delivery menus may show limited-time items or omit flavors that are unavailable at a specific restaurant.

The old article described seasonal pie availability correctly in principle, but it also stated that Bakers Square had no vegan or gluten-free pies. That blanket statement should be removed unless the company labels every current recipe and location that way. Bakers Square does state that its pies are produced in a facility that processes milk, egg, tree nuts, wheat, peanuts, and soybeans, which is a stronger and more useful warning for customers managing food allergies.

A gluten-sensitive menu is available at participating restaurants, but that does not make a pie gluten-free. Cross-contact and recipe details matter, so customers with allergies or celiac disease should use the restaurant’s allergen information rather than relying on a broad menu label.

The same caution applies to the old claim that all pies are made fresh in each restaurant every day with no preservatives. The accessible Bakers Square materials reviewed for this update do not support that exact statement. It is safer to describe the published flavors, ingredients, and facility warnings without inventing a production method the company does not currently promise.

Ownership Changes

Bakers Square’s ownership history also needs an update. BBQ Holdings completed its acquisition of Bakers Square and Village Inn in July 2021. The SEC transaction filing says Bakers Square Holdings and its subsidiaries became wholly owned by BBQ Holdings when that deal closed.

That is no longer the end of the ownership chain. MTY Food Group completed its acquisition of BBQ Holdings on September 27, 2022. MTY’s acquisition announcement says BBQ Holdings became an indirect wholly owned subsidiary of MTY. The practical description in 2026 is that Bakers Square sits inside BBQ Holdings under parent MTY Food Group.

The shared ownership structure also fits the pie-only model. Famous Dave’s sits in the same restaurant portfolio, letting Bakers Square sell pies at host restaurants without opening a full Bakers Square dining room.

For party-dessert comparisons, a Costco sheet cake runs about $24.99 to $27.99 and serves many more guests, while Dairy Queen cakes belong to the ice-cream-cake category. Compare serving count and dessert type, not sticker price alone.

Answers to Common Questions

How much is a slice of pie at Bakers Square?

Live menu examples reviewed in September 2026 put many slices around $5.79 to $7.89. Some locations can be lower or higher.

How much is a whole Bakers Square pie?

Standard whole pies on the live delivery menu reviewed run from about $18.69 to $26.19. Cheesecake and other cakes can cost much more.

Is Bakers Square pie free on Wednesday?

One eligible slice is free at participating restaurants when you buy an entrée and a beverage, dine in, and meet the promotion rules.

How many slices are in a Bakers Square pie?

The 2024 official pie menu listed standard whole pies as six slices. Portioning may vary, so confirm with the restaurant when serving size matters for an event.

Who owns Bakers Square?

Bakers Square is held through BBQ Holdings, which became an indirect wholly owned subsidiary of MTY Food Group in 2022.